top of page
  • Writer's pictureLeitner Varughese Warywoda

What Are My Options When the Insurance Company's Offer is Too Low?

When it comes to personal injury cases, receiving a fair settlement offer from an insurance company is crucial. However, there are instances when the initial offer falls far short of expectations. In this blog, we will explore the options available to individuals whose insurance company has presented them with an inadequate settlement offer. Understanding these options can help you pursue the compensation you deserve.

I. Understanding the Insurance Company's Role

Insurance companies have a responsibility to their policyholders, but it's important to recognize the potential conflict of interest that arises when they handle personal injury claims. Their primary goal is to minimize costs and maximize profits, often resulting in low settlement offers. Being aware of this inherent conflict is crucial to navigating the negotiation process effectively.

II. Evaluating the Initial Offer

Assessing the adequacy of an insurance company's settlement offer involves understanding the various factors that contribute to the value of your claim. Medical expenses, lost wages, pain and suffering, and future treatment costs should all be considered. Consulting with a personal injury attorney experienced in evaluating claims can help establish a fair estimation of your case's value.

III. Reasons for a Low Offer

Insurance companies employ several tactics to undervalue claims, such as disputing liability, emphasizing pre-existing conditions, downplaying the extent of injuries, or manipulating the facts of the case. Recognizing these strategies will enable you to better counter them during negotiations.

IV. Exploring Options

A. Negotiation Strategies

Effective negotiation skills can significantly impact the outcome of your settlement. Some key tips include gathering and organizing evidence, maintaining documentation of all related expenses, and presenting a compelling argument for why your claim deserves a higher offer. Engaging in a respectful and professional dialogue with the insurance company's representative is also crucial during this process.

B. Mediation and Alternative Dispute Resolution (ADR)

Mediation and ADR offer an alternative to traditional negotiation. These methods involve the assistance of a neutral third-party mediator who facilitates discussions between you and the insurance company. Mediation provides an opportunity to reach a resolution without resorting to litigation. It can be an effective way to address the inadequacy of the initial offer and work towards a fair settlement.

C. Filing a Lawsuit

If all attempts at negotiation or mediation prove unsuccessful, filing a personal injury lawsuit may be necessary. Litigation can provide the leverage needed to secure a fair settlement. It is crucial to consult with an experienced personal injury attorney before taking this step, as they can guide you through the complex legal process and ensure your rights are protected.

V. Working with an Attorney

Seeking legal representation is highly advisable in personal injury cases, especially when faced with an insufficient insurance offer. An experienced personal injury attorney will have the knowledge and expertise to evaluate your case's value, negotiate on your behalf, and determine the most suitable course of action. They will work tirelessly to ensure you receive fair compensation for your injuries.

If you already have an attorney, but you are not satisfied, it is your right to change attorneys at any time. In most situations, you can do this at no extra cost to yourself.


When the insurance company's offer falls short of what you deserve, it is essential to explore your options wisely. Understanding the insurance company's role, evaluating the offer, and recognizing the reasons behind a low offer are fundamental steps. From there, engaging in negotiation, considering alternative dispute resolution methods like mediation, or filing a lawsuit becomes crucial. Throughout this process, working with a skilled personal injury attorney can greatly increase your chances of achieving a fair and just settlement. Remember, you have the right to pursue the compensation that adequately covers your losses and helps you fully recover.


bottom of page